Where it crosses over

Avon pitches It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Murder as a “cat-and-mouse holiday romance-mystery,” and the publisher’s own shelving agrees. HarperCollins lists it in romance categories (romantic comedy, billionaires, second chances, action and adventure) and in mystery categories (cozy holiday mysteries and women sleuths) at the same time. That double listing is the hook: one half of the book is a whodunit with a suspect pool drawn from a small town’s founding families, and the other half is a rivals-since-childhood love story that has been building for years. It is the second Kiss, Merry, Kill book after Carter’s The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year, but Smexy Books’ review says the tie to the first novel is slight, so new readers can start here.

A missing heir, and a suspect who knows better

Ella and Liam grew up around the same mansion on opposite sides of the money line: she was the housekeeper’s kid, he was the grandson in line for everything. When Liam disappears after the Montgomery Christmas party, leaving blood in the driveway behind him, Ella looks guilty, especially since the jacket copy has her telling the whole town he was “so dead to her.” The catch is that she knows he is not dead at all. Liam has decided that being presumed dead is useful while he works out who would want a billionaire’s only heir out of the way, which leaves Ella chasing the man she is accused of murdering. A once-in-a-century storm then rolls in over their mountain town.

How it’s built

Smexy Books, which gave the novel a B+, says it is told mostly from Ella’s point of view with some chapters from Liam’s, moves between scenes from their past and the present, and cuts in excerpts from police interviews. Each chapter opens with a countdown to Christmas. The reviewer calls the romance a slow burn that ends in a happily ever after, and lists content warnings that include a parent’s death from cancer and medical debt.

Reader response

The book went on sale October 13 in hardcover and in a paperback whose first printing is a limited deluxe edition with stenciled edges. Early reader reviews keep coming back to the same mix: banter, a houseful of family secrets, a twist few saw coming, and a closed-door romance that runs on yearning rather than heat.

Publisher: Avon.