Where it crosses over

Gilmore built her readership on Dream Harbor, the cozy small-town series that began with The Pumpkin Spice Café. Maple Hollow keeps the quirky small town but moves the love story out to the edge of a dark forest and into paranormal territory. HarperCollins lists the tropes as fated mates, a grumpy hero, forced proximity, and found family, and on her website Gilmore says the new series has “a little more paranormal” in it than Dream Harbor. Amazon shelves the book in werewolf and shifter romance as well as small-town and holiday romance.

The fairy-tale nod is right there in the title, and on the jacket, where the heroine wears a red hood.

A story with an earlier life

HarperCollins notes that an earlier version of the story first appeared as A Curse of Blood and Wolves. Gilmore, who has also written as Melissa McTernan, says she wrote the original before The Pumpkin Spice Café took off, then rewrote and re-edited it to bring in Maple Hollow; a few names and story beats survive from that first version. She also says the older edition is no longer sold, and that readers who already know it are free to skip ahead to book two.

What’s next

Each book in the trilogy follows a different brother, and Gilmore says each one stands alone. Book two, Wild Wicked Mate, pairs Phoebe with Theo, the werewolf she has been friends with for years, and is due October 20, 2026, according to HarperCollins. The final book is planned for spring 2027.

Reader response

A month after release, the Kindle edition has 4 out of 5 stars on Amazon as of October 7. In a review quoted on the HarperCollins product page, Booklist called it “darker and edgier” than the Dream Harbor books.

Publisher: HarperCollins. Kindle: Amazon.