A Court of Splintered Harmony breaks records and splits its own fandom

Two weeks after midnight launch parties filled bookstore feeds, talk about Sarah J. Maas’s A Court of Splintered Harmony has moved from costumes to complaints. Slate wrote on November 5 that the sixth A Court of Thorns and Roses novel carries the lowest Goodreads rating of any main book in the series. The gripes it rounds up from social media and Reddit keep landing in the same places: the book opens by announcing a story told in four “movements” across three volumes, a good deal of the backstory lives in Maas’s Crescent City novel House of Flame and Shadow, and Azriel and Elain’s storyline has restarted ship wars that have reached Maas’s own comment sections.

The Bookseller’s Books on BookTok column (November 6) found the same mix on TikTok. Sales are not the issue: the column reports it has become the fastest-selling SFF book ever, passing Rebecca Yarros’s Onyx Storm, with 187,456 copies in its first week through Nielsen BookScan, and counts more than 87,200 videos under #acotar6 and #acosh combined. McDonald’s U.K. even got in on it with “MAC-OTAR” TikToks. The creators it spoke with also pointed to grumbling that some editions stand taller than the other five books on a shelf, and to doubts that this 352-page installment needed to be separate from the 896-page A Court of Forgotten Melody. BookToker Hannah (@hannah.s.books) told The Bookseller it “feels more like one part of an incomplete story arc.”

BBC Culture’s explainer (November 10) puts readers on both sides: some are simply glad to be back in Prythian, while others call the book “filler.” It also points out that Maas said on the Call Her Daddy podcast that this book and the two after it should be read as one story. A Court of Forgotten Melody is due January 12, 2027. Our release-day sales story has Bloomsbury’s first-day numbers.

Goodreads opens its 2026 Choice Awards ballot

Goodreads opened voting for its 2026 Choice Awards on November 10. Members get one vote per category through November 22. The top 10 in each category then move to a final round from November 24 to 29, and winners are announced December 3. Goodreads picks the 20 nominees per category from its own data on what members add, rate, and review, and this year’s field covers books published in the U.S. between November 12, 2025, and November 10, 2026.

The Romance ballot includes Abby Jimenez’s The Night We Met, Elle Kennedy’s Love Song, Elsie Silver’s Fever Dream, Kennedy Ryan’s Score, and Ana Huang’s King of Gluttony. On the Romantasy ballot, A Court of Splintered Harmony goes up against Rebecca Yarros’s Threshing Day, Callie Hart’s Brimstone, Carissa Broadbent’s The Lion & the Deathless Dark, and Liv Zander’s Crown Me Dead, the first book in the duet Sony Pictures is developing for film.

Elena Armas names the next Icarus University book

Elena Armas announced on November 6 that Luna Wolves will follow Alma Vampires in her Icarus University series. She calls it a rejected-mates shifter romance and says the series is built from interconnected standalones, so readers will meet its couple, Baz and Kiki, inside Alma Vampires this month. She is keeping the plot under wraps for now. U.S. preorders are not open yet, though she says some U.K. and European retailers are already taking orders.

Alma Vampires arrives from Berkley on November 17. It follows Valle Cepeda, a scholarship student who suddenly inherits a fashion empire, and Hadrian Cruz, a vampire whose century-old blood debt ties him to her.

Also circulating

  • Piper Lawson revealed the title of her second Ashford Academy Formula 1 romance: Running Hot, due from Berkley XO in August 2027. Theo Ashford, the rule-breaking heir of a racing family, lands a seat with a rival team and falls for Quinn Callahan, whose twin brother is his new teammate. A cover and preorder links are still to come.